Louisiana et al. v. New York et al.
- Insight
Louisiana, Arkansas, and Alabama have asked the United States Supreme Court to strike down shield laws that help protect abortion providers enacted by New York, Massachusetts, and California.
Case background
Louisiana, Arkansas, and Alabama have asked the United States Supreme Court to strike down the shield laws enacted by New York, Massachusetts, and California. Shield laws help protect abortion providers in states where abortion is legal from efforts to punish them under another state’s laws. Nineteen states and the District of Columbia have enacted such laws, including eight states that expressly protect the provision of telemedicine abortion care regardless of the patient’s location. An additional four states provide shield protections through executive orders exclusively. This case marks the first time that a state has initiated legal action against another state to invalidate its shield laws.
Who’s involvedWho’s involved
This case was brought by the Attorneys General of Louisiana, Arkansas, and Alabama (the chief legal officer in those respective states) against New York, Massachusetts, and California.
Bypassing other state and federal courts, they have gone directly to the U.S. Supreme Court, requesting it exercise its “original jurisdiction” and take up the case. The vast majority of cases arrive at the Supreme Court after a state supreme court or federal court has issued a ruling, but the Supreme Court has the discretion to hear disputes between states in the first instance. Such original jurisdiction cases make up a tiny portion of the Court’s overall caseload.
TimelineTimeline
Louisiana, Arkansas, and Alabama filed their initial pleading with the Supreme Court on September 30, 2026. New York, Massachusetts, and California have 60 days to file a brief in opposition. The Court then will decide whether to take up the case. It may do so based on the initial pleading and any brief in opposition, after conducting oral argument, or after ordering additional briefing. If at least five justices vote to take up the case, New York, Massachusetts, and California will file an answer to the initial pleading, and additional proceedings and oral argument may occur. Timelines of original jurisdiction cases vary.
ClaimsClaims
Louisiana, Arkansas, and Alabama assert four claims:
- First, they argue that shield laws violate the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the U.S. constitution, which requires states to respect each other’s laws and judicial proceedings.
- Second, they contend that shield laws violate the principle that all states are equal sovereigns, claiming that New York, Massachusetts, and California are “forcing” abortion into ban states.
- Third, they argue that shield laws violate federal judge-made law of public nuisance, which generally applies to conduct by one state that directly threatens the health or well-being of individuals in another state, comparing abortion medications to lethal weapons and addictive drugs.
- Fourth, the states claim that shield laws violate the Dormant Commerce Clause, which precludes states from passing laws that discriminate against interstate commerce, alleging that the sole purpose of the laws is to generate prohibited economic activity (the sale of abortion pills) across state lines.
Louisiana, Arkansas, and Alabama seek a judgment declaring the shield laws of New York, Massachusetts, and California unlawful and an injunction preventing officials in those states from enforcing the shield laws.
Fuel the Fight for Reproductive Rights
Your donation allows us to defend reproductive rights, change policies, and amplify voices around the globe.