Skip to content
Center for Reproductive Rights
Center for Reproductive Rights

Primary Menu

  • About
    • Overview
    • The Center’s Impact
    • Center Leadership & Staff
    • Annual Reports
    • Corporate Engagement
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Work
    • Overview
    • Litigation
    • Legal Policy and Advocacy
    • Resources & Research
    • Recent Case Highlights
    • Landmark Cases
    • Cases Archive
    • World’s Abortion Laws Map
    • After Roe Fell: Abortion Laws by State
  • Issues
    • Overview
    • Abortion
    • Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights
    • Assisted Reproduction
    • Contraception
    • Humanitarian Settings
    • Maternal Health
    • COVID-19
  • Regions
    • Overview
    • Global Advocacy
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Latin America and the Caribbean
    • United States
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Stories
    • Events
    • Center in the Spotlight
    • Press Releases
    • Statements
    • Press Room
    • Newsletters
  • Resources
    • Resources & Research
    • U.S. Abortion Rights: Resources
    • Maps
    • World Abortion Laws Map
    • After Roe Fell: Abortion Laws by State
    • Repro Red Flags: Agency Watch
  • Act
    • Overview
    • Give
    • Act
    • Learn
  • Donate
    • Become a Monthly Donor
    • Make a Donor Advised Fund Gift
    • Leave a Legacy Gift
    • Donate Gifts of Stock
    • Give a Gift in Honor
    • Attend an Event
    • Employee Matching Gifts
    • Mail a Check
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
Donate
icon-hamburger icon-magnifying-glass Donate
icon-magnifying-glass-teal

NYT Misleads on Pouillon Murder and Clinic Violence

Center for Reproductive Rights - Center for Reproductive Rights - search logo
search Close Close icon
Center for Reproductive Rights -
Menu Close Menu Close icon
Donate

Primary Menu

  • About
    • Overview
    • The Center’s Impact
    • Center Leadership & Staff
    • Annual Reports
    • Corporate Engagement
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Work
    • Overview
    • Litigation
    • Legal Policy and Advocacy
    • Resources & Research
    • Recent Case Highlights
    • Landmark Cases
    • Cases Archive
    • World’s Abortion Laws Map
    • After Roe Fell: Abortion Laws by State
  • Issues
    • Overview
    • Abortion
    • Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights
    • Assisted Reproduction
    • Contraception
    • Humanitarian Settings
    • Maternal Health
    • COVID-19
  • Regions
    • Overview
    • Global Advocacy
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Latin America and the Caribbean
    • United States
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Stories
    • Events
    • Center in the Spotlight
    • Press Releases
    • Statements
    • Press Room
    • Newsletters
  • Resources
    • Resources & Research
    • U.S. Abortion Rights: Resources
    • Maps
    • World Abortion Laws Map
    • After Roe Fell: Abortion Laws by State
    • Repro Red Flags: Agency Watch
  • Act
    • Overview
    • Give
    • Act
    • Learn
  • Donate
    • Become a Monthly Donor
    • Make a Donor Advised Fund Gift
    • Leave a Legacy Gift
    • Donate Gifts of Stock
    • Give a Gift in Honor
    • Attend an Event
    • Employee Matching Gifts
    • Mail a Check
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

Follow the Center

Donate Now

Join Now

10.16.2009

NYT Misleads on Pouillon Murder and Clinic Violence

Justin Goldberg

Share

  • facebook
  • Twitter
  • linkedin
  • Email id
Originally posted on RH Reality Check

There’s nothing new about the so-called liberal media bending over backwards to prove its impartiality — often at the expense of responsible reporting — but it doesn’t make it any less frustrating.  This past Saturday, I woke up to the latest offense in The New York Times’ coverage of last month’s shooting death of an anti-abortion protester in Michigan.  While the murder of Owosso resident James Pouillon is undoubtedly tragic, coverage in the Times has repeatedly cast this random and senseless incident misleadingly, portraying it, without evidence, as part of a larger abortion battle.



On the one hand, the Times’ coverage obfuscated police reports that abortion did not play a central role in the killing (one of two by the same alleged shooter on the same day).  On the other, the articles unduly romanticized the actions of anti-choice protesters, while completely ignoring the long history of violence, intimidation and harassment perpetrated against abortion providers.  As Randall Terry, founder and former leader of Operation Rescue, admitted to The Washington Post recently, the goal of anti-choice forces has been to “torment[]” providers, including medical residents, to reduce access for women to safe choices.



This weekend’s article “Abortion Foes Tell of Their Journey to the Streets” is probably the worst offender, declaring (in the lede) that Mr. Pouillon’s murder is proof that anti-choice protesters are under the same threat of violence as abortion providers. Really? Let’s just do the reporter’s job by looking, first and foremost, at the facts. Mr. Pouillon’s death is believed to be the first of a person protesting abortion. Meanwhile, anti-abortion violence, including clinic bombings, kidnappings, arson, and shootings, has spanned the last three decades.  The National Abortion Federation documents more than 6,100 violent acts in the U.S. and Canada since 1977.  



What’s more, the perpetrators of this violence are quite frequently well-connected to prominent anti-choice organizations and readily acknowledge their anti-abortion motivations. James Kopp, the convicted murderer of New York’s Dr. Barnett Slepian for example, was a well-known militant in the notorious anti-abortion terrorist organization, The Lambs of Christ. Paul Hill, who admitted killing Florida’s Dr. John Britton and his bodyguard, expressed no remorse after the shootings and told CBS News’ Connie Chung in 1994 that, “I know for a fact that I’m going to go to heaven when I die. I am certainly guilty of no crimes… My actions are honorable.”



In contrast, in the Pouillon case, the reported facts strongly indicate that the shooting was part of a random killing spree stemming from individual grudges — none of which were brought on by pro-choice sentiment. As authorities have reported, the suspect Harlan Drake shot a second victim, Mike Fuoss, an owner of a gravel pit, and planned to shoot a third, James Howe, who was a local Owosso realtor. Shiawassee County Sheriff’s Detective Lt. David Kirk told The Detroit News that there are no clear ties between the victims, but that Drake had separate interactions with each of his targets and that, “It didn’t appear to be a case where Pouillon was pro-life and Drake was pro-choice.”



Then there’s the Times’ unsubstantiated claims.  Two more articles published in the Times (“Abortion Protester Is Killed in Michigan” (Sept. 12), and “Memorial Held for Slain Anti-Abortion Protester” (Sept.17)) drew deeply spurious connections between Mr. Pouillon’s murder and that of Kansas abortion provider Dr. George Tiller.  Again, mere reference to the facts shows otherwise.  Scott Roeder, the suspect in Dr. Tiller’s murder, was a well-known anti-abortion activist, openly connected with Operation Rescue, a prominent anti-abortion organization, and has been linked to vandalism at another Kansas clinic. Mr. Roeder also had a noted violent record, including a 1996 conviction for criminal use of explosives. Mr. Drake, on the other hand, has no connections with the pro-choice movement and there have been no reports of a history of harassing members of the anti-choice movement.



Dr. Tiller was the eighth person murdered in attacks on abortion providers, while again, Mr. Pouillon’s shooting is believed to be the first of its kind (reported by The New York Times, incidentally). In addition, Dr. Tiller was the target of anti-abortion activists for years, actions which included an assassination attempt in which he was shot five times, and his clinic being vandalized.



In contrast, Mr. Pouillon has no known history of being harassed nor has even been mentioned by name by any pro-choice organization. He also has a long list of run-ins with the law, according to The Detroit Free Press, including a conviction of stalking a woman he who worked at an Owosso car dealership. As a more responsible paper, the Free Press, reports, Mr. Pouillon regularly protested at the auto dealership for its support of a pro-choice candidate and apparently targeted this female employee mistakenly believing, she says, that she had some connection to this pro-choice activity.



In the first comprehensive investigation of the battles waged against abortion providers, the Center for Reproductive Rights this year found that aggressive harassment as well as discriminatory legal restrictions and serious stigma are reducing the number of abortion providers.  Doctors and clinic staff operate under appalling circumstances, including death threats, dead animals left at their front door, break-ins at their homes, and being physically assaulted by protesters. They live in fear of violence.



Among other precautions, they carry bullet-proof vests, purchase elaborate security systems for their homes and offices, and change their daily routes to work. As one executive director of a Pennsylvania clinic who is regularly picketed by a protester at her home told us, “Every day, I work in a culture of terror. Every day, I worry about being shot or targeted, especially now that Dr. Tiller was murdered. That has increased a hundred fold. I have not felt more vulnerable. I’ve never felt this vulnerable in my job.” A moving video in which she talks about the difficulty of living with this fear and intimidation is here.



Overall, the Times’ recent coverage has been profoundly misleading, irresponsibly suggesting that Mr. Pouillon’s murder is an escalation in violence over abortion. On top of the recent tragedy, it has added an utterly avoidable injury — by equating a random shooting with a sustained and intentional campaign of intimidation, harassment and violence by anti-choice forces, it disregards the dangerous and sometimes, deadly environment in which abortion providers operate daily.  What journalists must remember is that a trumped-up “balance” in their reporting can actually cover up the truth, distort the meaning of violent acts like this one, and do far more harm than good.



This editorial was orginally posted on RH Reality Check. See what others are saying by clicking here >,


Related Posts

Azar v. Garza Amicus Brief

Abortion,United States,In the Courts

Complaint: Falls Church Healthcare Center et al. v. Norman Oliver et al.

Abortion,United States,In the Courts

Amicus Brief: State of California et al. v. Alex M. Azar et al.

Other Barriers, Contraception,United States,In the Courts

Sign up for email updates.

The most up-to-date news on reproductive rights, delivered straight to you.

Footer Menu

  • Careers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Gift Acceptance Policy
  • Contact Us

Center for Reproductive Rights
© (1992-2024)

Use of this site signifies agreement with our disclaimer and privacy policy.

Better Business Bureau Charity Watch Top Rated Center for Reproductive Rights
This site uses necessary, analytics and social media cookies to improve your experience and deliver targeted advertising. Click "Options" or click here to learn more and customize your cookie settings, otherwise please click "Accept" to proceed.
OPTIONSACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
CookieDurationDescription
_ga2 yearsThis cookie is installed by Google Analytics. The cookie is used to calculate visitor, session, campaign data and keep track of site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookies store information anonymously and assign a randomly generated number to identify unique visitors.
_gat_UA-6619340-11 minuteNo description
_gid1 dayThis cookie is installed by Google Analytics. The cookie is used to store information of how visitors use a website and helps in creating an analytics report of how the wbsite is doing. The data collected including the number visitors, the source where they have come from, and the pages viisted in an anonymous form.
_parsely_session30 minutesThis cookie is used to track the behavior of a user within the current session.
HotJar: _hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress30 minutesNo description
HotJar: _hjFirstSeen30 minutesNo description
HotJar: _hjid1 yearThis cookie is set by Hotjar. This cookie is set when the customer first lands on a page with the Hotjar script. It is used to persist the random user ID, unique to that site on the browser. This ensures that behavior in subsequent visits to the same site will be attributed to the same user ID.
HotJar: _hjIncludedInPageviewSample2 minutesNo description
HotJar: _hjIncludedInSessionSample2 minutesNo description
HotJar: _hjTLDTestsessionNo description
SSCVER1 year 24 daysThe domain of this cookie is owned by Nielsen. The cookie is used for online advertising by creating user profile based on their preferences.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
CookieDurationDescription
_fbp3 monthsThis cookie is set by Facebook to deliver advertisement when they are on Facebook or a digital platform powered by Facebook advertising after visiting this website.
fr3 monthsThe cookie is set by Facebook to show relevant advertisments to the users and measure and improve the advertisements. The cookie also tracks the behavior of the user across the web on sites that have Facebook pixel or Facebook social plugin.
IDE1 year 24 daysUsed by Google DoubleClick and stores information about how the user uses the website and any other advertisement before visiting the website. This is used to present users with ads that are relevant to them according to the user profile.
IMRID1 year 24 daysThe domain of this cookie is owned by Nielsen. The cookie is used for storing the start and end of the user session for nielsen statistics. It helps in consumer profiling for online advertising.
personalization_id2 yearsThis cookie is set by twitter.com. It is used integrate the sharing features of this social media. It also stores information about how the user uses the website for tracking and targeting.
TDID1 yearThe cookie is set by CloudFare service to store a unique ID to identify a returning users device which then is used for targeted advertising.
test_cookie15 minutesThis cookie is set by doubleclick.net. The purpose of the cookie is to determine if the user's browser supports cookies.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
CookieDurationDescription
adEdition1 dayNo description
akaas_MSNBC10 daysNo description
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional1 yearThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others1 yearNo description
geoEdition1 dayNo description
next-i18next1 yearNo description
SAVE & ACCEPT
Powered by CookieYes Logo
Scroll Up