County of Santa Clara v. HHS


Primary Content

This lawsuit challenges the "Denial of Care" rule issued earlier this month by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. The lawsuit was filed on May 28, 2019 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in coordination with Santa Clara County. The lawsuit argues that the rule is unconstitutional because it violates the First amendment by violating patients right to speech and expression and also violates the rights to privacy, liberty and equal dignity as protected by the Fifth Amendment. The new regulation would invite health care workers – doctors, nurses, EMTs, administrators and clerical staff – to deny medical treatment and services to patients because of personal religious or moral beliefs. Health care facilities that do not comply risk losing federal funding.  Because of this, health care facilities may do away with reproductive and LGBTQ services altogether, leaving millions without access to critical health care.

Plaintiff(s): Trust Women Seattle, Hartford GYN, Whitman-Walker Health, Bradbury-Sullivan LGBT Community Center, Los Angeles LGBT Center, Center on Halsted, Mazzoni Center, GLMA, Association of Gay and Lesbian Psychiatrists, Medical Students for Choice

Center Attorney(s): Genevieve Scott

Co-Counsel/Cooperating Attorneys: Jamie A. Gliksberg at LAMBDA Legal Defense and Education Fund, Lee H. Rubin at Mayer Brown LLP, Richard B. Katskee at Americans United for Separation of Church and State, James R. Williams, Greta S. Hansen, Laura S. Trice, Mary E. Hanna-Weir, Susan P. Greenberg, and H. Luke Edward Office of the County Counsel, County of Santa Clara

Summary: The lawsuit argues that the Denial of Care rule is unconstitutional because it advances specific religious beliefs (in violation of the First amendment); violates the patients rights to privacy, liberty and equal dignity as guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment. It could also lead to many LGBTQ patients not fully disclosing their identity and medical history for fear of discrimination, resulting in improper or incomplete care.

The lawsuit also asserts that HHS violated the federal Administrative Procedure Act in creating the rule by arbitrarily and capriciously failing to consider the impact on patients. On June 12, 2019, Lambda Legal, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the Center for Reproductive Rights, and the County of Santa Clara (“County”) urged the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California to issue an injunction blocking implementation of the Denial-of-Care rule to protect patients nationwide while the coalition’s lawsuit is pending.